The Beauty Expert
SKIN
BEAUTY
SLEEP
4 min read
4min read
We tested the 5 most popular sleep masks
This is the surprising winner
The Beauty Expert
August 12, 2025
You've probably seen sleep masks everywhere lately. On flights, in skincare routines, all over TikTok. Words like "total blackout," "silk comfort," and "deeper sleep" keep showing up. And it makes sense: more people than ever are realising that light is one of the biggest disruptors of quality sleep. But what actually separates a great sleep mask from one that ends up in your bedside drawer? Three things matter more than you'd think.
Key features of our winning sleep mask
100% Light-Blocking
Engineered to block every trace of light. No gaps at the nose, sides, or brow. Total darkness, every night.
Ultra-Comfortable for Every Sleep Position
An ultra-slim profile that feels barely there, whether you sleep on your back, side, or stomach. No bulk, no pressure on your eyes.
Stays On All Night
Designed to stay exactly where you put it. No riding up, no slipping off, no midnight adjustments. Still in place when your alarm goes off.
Gentle on Your Skin
23 Momme mulberry silk with silver ion technology eliminates 99.7% of bacteria. The kindest material you can press against the delicate skin around your eyes. It reduced my sleep creases, puffiness, and under-eye irritation overnight.
5 Popular Sleep Masks Put to the Test
With so many options, from cheap Amazon picks to premium silk brands, it's easy to feel overwhelmed. Let's be honest: not all sleep masks are created equal. Differences in design, material, and fit can make a world of difference in how well you actually sleep.
To find out which masks truly deliver, we tested five of the most popular options for 30 nights, scoring them on five criteria:
Light Blocking
How well does it seal out every trace of light around the nose, sides, and brow?
Comfort & Fit
Does it feel good on your face for 8 hours? Weight, pressure, breathability.
Stays On All Night
Does it shift, ride up, or slip off while you sleep?
Skin-Friendly Material
Is the fabric gentle enough to press against the delicate skin around your eyes, every single night? Does it reduce friction that causes sleep creases and morning puffiness, or make it worse?
Overall Sleep Quality
The bottom line: does it actually help you sleep deeper and wake up more refreshed?
We expected a close race, but one mask stood out from the pack. Below you'll find our complete evaluation, including our pick for the clear winner.
#1: The Antibacterial Silk Sleep Mask
(4.8 / 5)
The Deep Sleep Mask from Dore & Rose is what a purpose-built sleep mask should be. It blocks 100% of light with no gaps at the nose or sides. Even for side sleepers, the seal stays intact all night.
What makes this mask exceptional is the 23 Momme mulberry silk with silver ion technology, which eliminates 99.7% of bacteria. This fabric pressed against your eyes is actually working for your skin, not against it - reducing sleep creases, puffiness, and under-eye bags overnight. Despite its generous padding, the mask feels surprisingly light, soft, and delicate against your face. You'll forget you're wearing it. It's dermatologist-designed, Oeko-Tex® certified, and backed by over 500,000 sales. In short: the mask other brands are trying to catch up to.
Light Blocking
9.6
Comfort & Fit
9.7
Stays On All Night
9.4
Skin-Friendly Material
9.9
Overall Sleep Quality
9.5
⚠️ Limited Availability: Dore & Rose has sold out 7 times.
Stock is limited. If you've been considering upgrading your sleep, now is the time to act.
CHECK AVAILABILITY →
#2: The Gimmicky Bluetooth Mask
(3.9 / 5)
It sounds like a great idea: a sleep mask with built-in speakers so you can fall asleep to music or podcasts. In practice? It's heavy, bulky, and the speakers press into your temples. The battery needs charging every few nights, and the Bluetooth connection drops more often than you'd expect. Most people stop using the audio within a week and are left with an uncomfortable mask, although it blocks the light very well.
Light Blocking
9.1
Comfort & Fit
6.5
Stays On All Night
7.0
Skin-Friendly Material
5.5
Overall Sleep Quality
6.5
Check availability
#3: The Cheap Silk Amazon Mask
(3.7 / 5)
You've seen it, the $12 silk mask with thousands of 5-star reviews on Amazon. It looks premium in the photos, but the reality is thin padding, light leaking in from every angle, and an elastic strap that loses tension within weeks. The silk itself is low-grade and starts pilling after a few washes. You'll replace it three times a year and still never get a proper blackout.
Light Blocking
6.5
Comfort & Fit
6.8
Stays On All Night
6.2
Skin-Friendly Material
7.6
Overall Sleep Quality
6.4
Check availability
#4: The Synthetic Satin Mask
(3.4 / 5)
This is the one that tricks you. It looks and feels like silk at first: smooth, shiny, affordable. But it's polyester satin, and your skin knows the difference. It traps heat, doesn't breathe, and creates friction against delicate under-eye skin overnight. After a few weeks, you notice the fabric isn't doing your skin any favours. The mask that promises luxury but delivers the opposite.
Light Blocking
Comfort & Fit
6.7
Stays On All Night
6.2
Skin-Friendly Material
4.7
Overall Sleep Quality
6.0
Check availability
#5: The Cotton Drugstore Mask
(3.2 / 5)
The default choice. It's cheap, it's everywhere, and it does the bare minimum. The fit is usually fine and it blocks some light, but cotton absorbs your skin's natural moisture and creates friction, exactly what you don't want against your eyes for 8 hours. It's the mask you buy when you don't think it matters. Once you try something better, you won't go back.
Light Blocking
6.3
Comfort & Fit
6.1
Stays On All Night
6.0
Skin-Friendly Material
5.8
Overall Sleep Quality
5.6
Check availability
The winner is clear...
After testing five of the most popular sleep masks, the pattern was obvious: most masks force you to compromise. Good blackout but uncomfortable material. Soft fabric but light leaking in. Decent fit but falls apart after a few weeks.
The Antibacterial Silk Sleep Mask from Dore & Rose is the only one that doesn't ask you to choose. Total blackout, silk that's actually good for your skin, and a fit that stays put all night. For deeper, uninterrupted sleep - it's not a close contest.
Shop now →